Nightmare of You Tickets

Concert Tickets Pop / Rock Tickets Nightmare of You Tickets

More Info

Nightmare of You Tickets

Nightmare of You brings melodic indie pop-rock into focus with bright guitars, sharp hooks, wry lyricism, and a devoted following rooted in the mid-2000s indie and emo-adjacent scene. If you're looking for Nightmare of You tickets, you likely already know the pull of songs like "I Want to Be Buried in Your Backyard" and "The Days Go By Oh So Slow" — fan favorites built for intimate rooms and loud singalongs.

This page covers everything you need — from what to expect at a Nightmare of You live show to finding the right seats and buying with confidence.

About Nightmare of You

Nightmare of You is an American indie rock band from Long Island, New York, formed in 2004 and led by Brandon Reilly on vocals and guitar. Reilly, previously of The Movielife, helped shape the band's literate, melodic pop-rock identity alongside founding-era guitarist Joe McCaffrey, bassist Ryan Heil, and drummer Sammy Siegler. Their sound sits between the emo/pop-punk community connected to their members' earlier work and a more polished indie-pop sensibility built around jangly guitars, clever lyrics, and sharp melodies.

The band's self-titled debut album, Nightmare of You, arrived in 2005 and became their defining release. Praised for its melodic, literate indie pop-rock, the album introduced the songs that remain central to the band's cult following, including "I Want to Be Buried in Your Backyard," "The Days Go By Oh So Slow," and "Dear Scene, I Wish I Were Deaf." The follow-up Bang (EP) continued the melodic direction in 2007, while Infomaniac expanded the band's sound in 2009.

Nightmare of You's primary activity ran through the mid-2000s into the early 2010s, with singles "Give Us a Kiss" and "Out of My Mind" arriving in 2012. Their fanbase has remained loyal, with ongoing interest in anniversary and reunion-style appearances reflecting the band's lasting appeal within indie, emo-adjacent, and pop-rock circles. For fans who discovered the debut in its original era or found the band later, Nightmare of You tickets offer a chance to reconnect with a catalog that has held its place as a cult favorite.

Why You Want to See Nightmare of You Live

A Nightmare of You concert is built around melody, lyric detail, and the kind of fan connection that thrives in clubs, music halls, and small theaters. Their songs combine polished indie pop-rock craft with darker humor and a post-punk-leaning edge, giving the live show a distinct personality: bright and hook-driven, but never generic.

The biggest live moments come from the songs fans know by heart. Tracks from the self-titled debut carry the strongest singalong energy, especially "I Want to Be Buried in Your Backyard," "The Days Go By Oh So Slow," and "Dear Scene, I Wish I Were Deaf." Brandon Reilly's distinctive vocals and the band's melodic guitar work are central to the experience, making the songs feel immediate in a close-room setting.

Because Nightmare of You's following is devoted and niche, the crowd experience has a personal quality. These shows draw fans of mid-2000s indie rock, emo-adjacent pop-rock, and related scenes — the kind of audience that responds loudly to deep catalog favorites and treats each appearance as something special.

What to Expect at a Nightmare of You Concert

A Nightmare of You concert typically centers on fan-favorite material from their self-titled debut and Infomaniac, with the strongest reactions reserved for the melodic singles that built the band's reputation. Their live identity is suited to club and small-theater rooms, where the details of the songs — vocals, lyrics, and guitar hooks — stay close to the audience.

The setlist character leans toward the band's cult-favorite catalog. Expect songs from Nightmare of You (2005) to carry much of the emotional weight, with Infomaniac material adding more range and texture. Their later singles, including "Give Us a Kiss" and "Out of My Mind," also represent the band's later-era activity.

The atmosphere is intimate and fan-driven. Rather than relying on large-scale spectacle, Nightmare of You's production style fits the room: focused sound, close audience connection, and a performance built around the songs themselves. In that setting, singalong-driven favorites can become the defining moments of the night.

Additional Performer Information

Nightmare of You Albums

Nightmare of You's catalog is compact, melodic, and closely tied to their cult following in indie and emo-adjacent pop-rock:

Nightmare of You (2005) — Debut self-titled album; the band's defining release, praised for melodic, literate indie pop-rock.
Bang (EP) (2007) — Follow-up EP continuing the band's melodic pop-rock direction.
Infomaniac (2009) — Second full-length studio album, expanding the band's sound.
Give Us a Kiss (Single) (2012) — Later single release.
Out of My Mind (Single) (2012) — Later single release.

Popular Nightmare of You Songs

These are the tracks fans most anticipate at a live Nightmare of You concert — expect strong crowd reactions throughout:

"I Want to Be Buried in Your Backyard"
"The Days Go By Oh So Slow"
"Dear Scene, I Wish I Were Deaf"
"My Name Is Trouble"
"The Studted Press Stud"
"You, Me, and Everyone We Know"
"Why Am I Always Right"
"It's Not Enough Until It's Killing Me"
"Box of Hops"
"Marry Me"

Similar Artists and Concerts You Might Like

If you're a Nightmare of You fan, the following indie rock artists tend to appeal to the same crowd — melodic, emotionally connected, and rooted in the same broader mid-2000s scene:

The Movielife Tickets
Taking Back Sunday Tickets
Brand New Tickets
Jimmy Eat World Tickets
The Early November Tickets
Saves the Day Tickets
Straylight Run Tickets
Death Cab for Cutie Tickets
The Get Up Kids Tickets
Motion City Soundtrack Tickets

How Much Do Tickets to Nightmare of You Cost?

Nightmare of You ticket prices vary based on the city, venue, date, seat location, and demand. Floor, front-of-stage, and VIP options are in high demand, while lawn and upper-level sections offer strong value.

Because Nightmare of You typically fits club, music hall, and small-theater settings, the room itself can shape the buying experience. In more intimate venues, the best sightlines and closest available areas may draw attention quickly, especially for reunion-interest appearances, anniversary-style demand, or dates in markets with strong indie and emo-adjacent fan communities.

Buying earlier generally gives you more room to compare sections, rows, and price points. As show night gets closer and available inventory narrows, the best remaining listings can become harder to secure — especially if you are trying to sit with a group or stay close to the stage.

> No hidden fees. At Box Office Ticket Sales, the price you see is the price you pay. All fees are shown before checkout — no surprise charges when you reach the final step.

How to Buy Nightmare of You Tickets

Getting your tickets through BoxOfficeTicketSales.com is fast and straightforward. Here's how the process works:

Browse Nightmare of You tour dates — Search for Nightmare of You tickets and select the city and date that fit your schedule
Pick your seats — Use the interactive seating map to compare sections, rows, views, and real-time pricing side by side
Secure checkout — Pay with a credit card, PayPal, Apple Pay, or Affirm for flexible payment options
Receive your tickets — Digital tickets are delivered to your email or mobile wallet before the show, ready to scan at the venue entrance

Every order is backed by our 100% verified ticket guarantee and on-time delivery promise. Once your order is confirmed, you'll receive an email with your invoice and everything you need before show night.

Nightmare of You Seating Guide

Nightmare of You shows are most at home in clubs, music halls, and small theaters. Where you stand or sit shapes the experience, so it is worth comparing your options before buying — especially if you want to be close for the singalong-heavy favorites.

Best Seats for a Nightmare of You Concert

The right seat depends on what kind of show experience you're after:

Best value: Standard admission areas or seats farther back in the room — a strong choice for fans who want the full crowd energy while keeping price in mind.
Closest to the stage: Front-of-room or closest-to-stage spots — the best fit if you want maximum proximity to Brandon Reilly's vocals, the guitar work, and the band's intimate live feel.
Best overall experience: Centered reserved seats or mid-room viewing areas — a balanced option with clear sightlines, strong sound, and enough distance to take in the full performance.
For groups: Coordinate contiguous reserved sections early when available, since blocks of seats in popular small-theater areas can disappear quickly.

Nightmare of You Seating Chart

You can view an interactive seating map for Nightmare of You shows directly on BoxOfficeTicketSales.com while browsing available listings. The map lets you compare sections side by side, check row depth and distance from the stage, and see real-time pricing for what's currently available — all before committing to a purchase.

Can I See Where My Seats Are?

Yes. The interactive seat map on BoxOfficeTicketSales.com shows your exact section and row placement before you buy. Use it to understand your angle to the stage, your distance from the front, and whether you're close to the stage, farther back in the room, or in a reserved section when offered — so the tickets you choose match exactly what you're looking for on show night.

Getting Ready for Show Night

Once your tickets are confirmed, a little preparation makes the whole evening run smoother — from the parking lot to the final encore.

Download your tickets before you leave. Cell service around clubs, music halls, and small theaters gets congested as show time approaches. Save your tickets to your phone's wallet or screenshot them before heading out so you're not searching at the gate.
Charge your phone fully. Digital ticketing is standard at most venues, and your phone is your entry. A portable battery pack is worth having for a full evening out.
Arrive before the listed start time. Shows often begin at or near the listed start time — arriving on time means you're in your seat when the music starts.
Check the venue's bag policy before you go. Individual venues set their own security guidelines; reviewing them before you leave home prevents delays at the entrance.

Is Box Office Ticket Sales Legit?

Yes — Box Office Ticket Sales is a fully verified, secure ticketing platform that has served over 1 million customers since 2012. When you buy Nightmare of You tickets through BoxOfficeTicketSales.com, here's what backs every purchase:

100% verified ticket listings — every listing is authenticated before it reaches you
On-time delivery guarantee — your tickets arrive before the event, or we make it right
All seats together unless explicitly noted otherwise in the listing
SSL-encrypted checkout — your payment information is protected at every step
24/7 TrustGuard monitoring — active security oversight around the clock
Access to 125,000+ live events nationwide, from indie rock concerts to major sports and entertainment
BoxOfficeTicketSales.com has been selling tickets for 21 years and is BBB accredited

Nightmare of You shows — particularly reunion-interest dates, anniversary-style appearances, and intimate music hall stops — move fast. The best-value listings tend to disappear well before show night. If you have a specific date or city in mind, now is the time to move. Browse Nightmare of You tickets and lock in your seats before inventory tightens.

Need Help With Your Nightmare of You Tickets?

Our support team is available before, during, and after your purchase. Reach us through any of these channels:

Live chat: Log in to your account at BoxOfficeTicketSales.com to chat with an agent
Email: customersupport@boxofficeticketsales.com
Phone: Call the number on your order confirmation invoice
Buy by phone: Call 1-800-515-2171 to purchase tickets directly with a representative